User:voorts/XfD log/Select XfDs
< User:Voorts | XfD log
This is a list of XfD nominations and !votes that I have selected as representative of my XfD participation. Please see my AfD stats and XfD stats (but cf. WP:NOTAFDSTATS).
- Nathan Hale Arts Magnet Elementary School – AfD nomination based on SIGCOV concerns with source-by-source analysis.
- Isla Phillips – RevDel nomination based on NPF and GNG concerns.
- Imprisonment of Eddie Núñez – AfD nomination based on BLP1E, BLPCRIME, and NOTNEWS concerns.
- 2024 New York City stabbing spree – AfD nomination based on NCRIME, PERSISTENCE, and GEOSCOPE.
XfDs where I changed my mind (or should have)
[edit]- A Mile in His Shoes – My first AfD nomination; I was too restrictive in my view of SIGCOV.
- Restricted military area – AfD nomination based on NOTDICT after another editor's PROD was removed; I changed my mind when another editor rescued the article.
- Intellectual property policy – I probably should have brought my concerns over the scope of the article to the talk page, rather than to AfD for nuking.
- Agent 47 – I would likely !vote keep now based on the sourcing provided; I think I was being too narrow in evaluating the sources as I did.
- American Whiskey Trail – I changed my mind twice during this AfD: once to merge as an ATD, and then to keep after a back-and-forth on NOTTRAVELGUIDE and NLIST with Cunard (talk).
XfDs where I would have closed differently
[edit]- The Go Getters – I would have closed this as keep rather than no consensus, but I believe no consensus was within the closer's discretion.
- Amendment to allege use – I stand by this nomination because I do not believe the sourcing was sufficiently reliable or in depth. However, I recognize the strength of and support for the keep arguments and would have closed this as no consensus.